# Export and live-wiki comparison

This is a research inventory, not a merge decision. It compares the 93 successful canonical pages in `manifest.json` with all 29 source entries in `docs/migration-manifest.json`. The comparison is page-level: a live course page can be new-only even when its surrounding year/programme taxonomy overlaps an exported index page. Five public navigation aliases redirect to canonical description routes and are not duplicated in the capture.

## New live-wiki pages with no exported page equivalent

These 87 successful live pages have no one-to-one page in the export. Course titles are listed so every captured course page is concretely classified rather than represented only by a count.

| Live route or family | Count | Captured pages | Classification |
| --- | ---: | --- | --- |
| `/computer-science/course-description` | 1 | Course Description | The export has no Computer Science programme page; its bachelor programme is Data Science and Artificial Intelligence. The `/computer-science` navigation alias redirects here. |
| `/computer-science/year-1/**` | 12 | Discrete Math; Introduction to Computer Science; Procedural Programming; Calculus; Logic; Objects in Programming; Computer Architecture; Data Structures and Algorithms; Linear Algebra; Databases; Algorithmic Design; Statistics | New course-level hierarchy organized by year and period; the export has no corresponding course pages. |
| `/computer-science/year-2/**` | 14 | Intelligent User Interfaces; Introduction to Artificial Intelligence; Operating Systems; Computer Networks; Software Engineering and Architectures; Computer Security; Embedded Programming; Parallel Programming; Numerical Methods; Principles of Programming Languages; M2-1: AI and Machine Learning; M2-1: Intelligent Interaction; M2-2: Cybersecurity; M2-2: High Performance Computing | New course/elective pages; no exported equivalents. |
| `/computer-science/year-3/**` | 16 | Digital Society; Game Theory; Graph Theory; Introduction to Quantum Computing; Robotics and Embedded Systems; Ubiquitous Computing & Internet of Things; Block Chains; Cryptography; Immersive Technologies; Introduction to Bio-Informatics; Large Scale IT and Cloud Computing; Software and Systems Verification; Startup Engineering: Building Scalable Tech Ventures; The History and Philosophy of Computing; Operating Systems; Theory of Computing | New course/elective pages; no exported equivalents. |
| `/data-science-and-artificial-intelligence/year-1/**` | 12 | Discrete Mathematics; Introduction to Data Science and Artificial Intelligence; Procedural Programming; Calculus; Logic; Objects in Programming; Data Structures and Algorithms; Linear Algebra; Principles of Data Science; Computational and Cognitive Neuroscience; Numerical Methods; Software Engineering | The exported Year 1 page is only a schedule/index shell and has no individual course pages. |
| `/data-science-and-artificial-intelligence/year-2/**` | 13 | Databases; Graph Theory; Probability and Statistics; Machine Learning; Reasoning Techniques; Simulation and Statistical Analysis; Human Computer Interaction & Affective Computing; Mathematical Modelling; Natural Language Processing; Game Theory; Introduction to Image & Video Processing; Linear Programming; Philosophy & Artificial Intelligence | The exported Year 2 branch contains projects and an honours placeholder, not these course pages. |
| `/data-science-and-artificial-intelligence/year-3/**` | 16 | Digital Society; Game Theory; Introduction to Quantum Computing; Multi-Scale Modelling of Biological Systems; Robotics and Embedded Systems; Semantic Web; Business Process & Knowledge Management; Computer Security; Introduction to Bio-Informatics; Large Scale IT and Cloud Computing; Logic for Artificial Intelligence; Parallel Programming; Recommender Systems; Data Analysis; Intelligent Systems; Operations Research | The exported Year 3 branch contains thesis/project/study-abroad material, not these course pages. |
| `/useful-guides/housing-guide` | 1 | Housing Guide | New 2025 housing-market and scam-avoidance guide; the exported Handy Locations page only names study/food-location categories. |
| `/useful-guides/linux-tricks` | 1 | Linux Tricks | Linux-specific Eduroam, VPN, file-service, and remote-desktop advice; there is no matching exported page. |
| `/useful-guides/survivingdacs` | 1 | DACS Survival Guide | Broad study, projects, exams, programming, mathematics, and student-life advice; there is no one-to-one export page. |

## Exported pages with no obvious live-wiki page equivalent

All seven exported project pages are called out explicitly. Year landing pages are included because their apparent live category URLs are soft 404s; their taxonomy is compared separately below.

| Export source path | Exported topic | Evidence/classification |
| --- | --- | --- |
| `pages/study/msv_incognito.txt` | MSV Incognito association | The live home page links the association but has no association-history/membership page. |
| `pages/study/bachelor/year_1.txt` | Bachelor Year 1 index and schedule | No valid live Year 1 landing page; live leaf courses are a structural overlap only. |
| `pages/study/bachelor/year_1/project_1-1.txt` | Project 1-1 | Exported project page; no live project page. |
| `pages/study/bachelor/year_1/project_1-2.txt` | Project 1-2 | Exported project page; no live project page. |
| `pages/study/bachelor/year_2.txt` | Bachelor Year 2 index and schedule | No valid live Year 2 landing page; live leaf courses are a structural overlap only. |
| `pages/study/bachelor/year_2/honours_programme.txt` | Year 2 honours programme | No live honours page. |
| `pages/study/bachelor/year_2/project_2-1.txt` | Project 2-1 | Exported project page; no live project page. |
| `pages/study/bachelor/year_2/project_2-2.txt` | Project 2-2 | Exported project page; no live project page. |
| `pages/study/bachelor/year_3.txt` | Bachelor Year 3 index and schedule | No valid live Year 3 landing page; live leaf courses are a structural overlap only. |
| `pages/study/bachelor/year_3/bachelors_thesis.txt` | Bachelor thesis | No live thesis page. |
| `pages/study/bachelor/year_3/honours_programme.txt` | Year 3 honours programme | No live honours page. |
| `pages/study/bachelor/year_3/project_3-1.txt` | Project 3-1 | Exported project page; no live project page. |
| `pages/study/bachelor/year_3/study_abroad.txt` | Study abroad | No live study-abroad page. |
| `pages/study/master_ai/year_1.txt` | MSc AI Year 1 index | The live MSc AI branch has only a sparse course-description page and no year hierarchy. |
| `pages/study/master_ai/year_1/project_mai_1.txt` | MSc AI Research Project 1 | Exported project page; no live project page. |
| `pages/study/master_ai/year_1/project_mai_2.txt` | MSc AI Research Project 2 | Exported project page; no live project page. |
| `pages/study/master_ai/year_2.txt` | MSc AI Year 2 index | No live MSc AI Year 2 page. |
| `pages/study/master_dsdm/year_1.txt` | MSc DSDM Year 1 index | The live DSDM branch has only a sparse course-description page and no year hierarchy. |
| `pages/study/master_dsdm/year_2.txt` | MSc DSDM Year 2 index | No live DSDM Year 2 page. |
| `pages/study/useful_information/pages/dke_locations.txt` | DKE/DACS teaching locations | No live locations page. |
| `pages/study/useful_information/pages/handy_locations.txt` | Study, food, and other locations | The Housing Guide is materially different and is not an equivalent. |
| `pages/study/useful_information/pages/it_services.txt` | General UM IT services | Linux Tricks overlaps a few technologies but is Linux-specific and not a replacement for the exported service-desk, portal, enrolment, grades, VPN, and printing page. |

## Overlapping topics and substantive differences

| Export source path | Live URL | Substantive difference |
| --- | --- | --- |
| `pages/start.txt` + `pages/study.txt` | `https://wiki.msvincognito.nl/` | The export has association/registration/editing instructions, official links, Maastricht University context, and programme descriptions. The live home is a short DACS landing page linking four programme areas and Useful Guides. |
| `pages/study/bachelor.txt` | `https://wiki.msvincognito.nl/data-science-and-artificial-intelligence/course-description` | Both identify the Data Science and Artificial Intelligence bachelor area. The export explains the programme index and contribution workflow; the canonical live route currently contains only a sparse “Course Description / #Hello” page. The base navigation route redirects here. |
| `pages/study/bachelor/year_1.txt` | `https://wiki.msvincognito.nl/data-science-and-artificial-intelligence/year-1/period-1/discrete-mathematics` (representative of 12 Year 1 leaf pages) | The export is a year index with a missing schedule image and page-creation controls. The live wiki has period/course leaf pages but its Year 1 and period category URLs render soft 404s. |
| `pages/study/bachelor/year_2.txt` | `https://wiki.msvincognito.nl/data-science-and-artificial-intelligence/year-2/period-1/databases` (representative of 13 Year 2 leaf pages) | The export is a schedule/index shell plus upload instructions. The live wiki replaces that organization with period/elective course leaves and no valid Year 2 landing page. |
| `pages/study/bachelor/year_3.txt` | `https://wiki.msvincognito.nl/data-science-and-artificial-intelligence/year-3/period-4/data-analysis` (representative of 16 Year 3 leaf pages) | The export discusses thesis timing and indexes thesis/project/study-abroad pages. The live branch lists course/elective leaves and contains no thesis or project page. |
| `pages/study/master_ai.txt` | `https://wiki.msvincognito.nl/artificial-intelligence/course-description` | Both label the MSc Artificial Intelligence area. The export describes course summaries, exams, year navigation, and contribution flow; the canonical live route is currently a sparse “Course Description / #Hello” page with no year/course content. The base navigation route redirects here. |
| `pages/study/master_dsdm.txt` | `https://wiki.msvincognito.nl/data-science-for-decision-making/course-description` | Both label the MSc Data Science for Decision Making area. The export has year navigation and contribution context; the canonical live route contains only the sparse description placeholder. The base navigation route redirects here. |
| `pages/study/useful_information.txt` | `https://wiki.msvincognito.nl/useful-guides/description` | The export indexes locations, IT services, and laptop advice. The canonical live index instead presents Housing, Laptop Buying Advice, Linux Tricks, and Surviving DACS, and claims the guides are updated “somewhat regularly.” The `/useful-guides` navigation alias redirects here. |
| `pages/study/useful_information/pages/laptop_buy_advice.txt` | `https://wiki.msvincognito.nl/useful-guides/laptop-buying-advice` | The live page preserves and edits the exported tier guide, marks it as last updated 2021, and adds a current minimum of 16 GB RAM/512 GB SSD, Apple M-series compatibility, and an Nvidia/CUDA recommendation for data-science programmes. |

## Navigation placeholders excluded from the capture

Public navigation enumerated 31 category URLs that return HTTP 200 but render exactly `404` and `This page could not be found.` They are navigation/taxonomy placeholders, not content pages, so the crawler excludes them and `manifest.json` has no failures. All leaf pages reachable through the same public navigation were retained.

| Route family | Excluded count | Exact category suffixes |
| --- | ---: | --- |
| `/computer-science/year-1` | 5 | year root; `period-1`; `period-2`; `period-4`; `period-5` |
| `/computer-science/year-2` | 7 | year root; `period-1`; `period-2`; `period-4`; `period-5`; `semester-1-electives`; `semester-2-electives` |
| `/computer-science/year-3` | 4 | year root; `period-1-electives`; `period-2-electives`; `period-4` |
| `/data-science-and-artificial-intelligence/year-1` | 5 | year root; `period-1`; `period-2`; `period-4`; `period-5` |
| `/data-science-and-artificial-intelligence/year-2` | 6 | year root; `period-1`; `period-2`; `period-4`; `period-5`; `period-5-electives` |
| `/data-science-and-artificial-intelligence/year-3` | 4 | year root; `period-1-electives`; `period-2-electives`; `period-4` |